Why Caitlyn Jenner is NOT a Hero to me.

By June 3, 2015Life, Politics, Television, Women

 I have been biting my tongue on the Caitlyn Jenner media tidal wave. I am now going to break my silence and I am sure the blowback from this will be immense but I feel that it has to be said. Caitlyn Jenner is not a hero. Caitlyn Jenner is just a girl. 

Firstly congrats to her for finally living her truth as her true self. As a person who has put on faces and toughed out being in a bad situation and living a “lie” I get it. I do. But, and this is a HUGE but, in the 70’s after Bruce (I am using her former name because she was Bruce in the 70’s not because I don’t acknowledge fully who she is today, but to refer to her former life as it was) had 2 kids with his FIRST wife, he came out. He told her the whole deal. He was really a woman and that is what he wanted to do. Become his true self. He had the means to transition then. His wife, after first responding with denial and therapy finally respected Bruce’s choice but because she didn’t want to be married to a woman, they divorced. 

While he was SEPARATED from his first wife, Bruce took up with another woman, meeting her at the Playboy mansion. He presented himself as a heterosexual man to her. Mind you this was at the same time he had just TOLD his wife that he was really a woman. He was not upfront with her. He didn’t tell her his secret, instead he wined and dined this woman and married her. Again having TWO children with her. Then again after a few years he told his second wife his big secret, that he was really a woman and wanted to transition.

He got the adams apple surgery and started to take hormones. When his kids started asking why Daddy had boobs his second wife realized that she too didn’t want to be married to a woman and filed for divorce.  This now makes 4 kids that were partially abandoned by him. He was not a good father to them. One ex-wife even opted to not to get child support from him. But he was not there for birthdays, christmas’s, nothing.

Then he changed his mind yet again, stopping the hormone treatments. He again was presenting himself as a hetero man. Bruce meets Kris and her circus of fame and he rides that wave for YEARS and has ANOTHER TWO KIDS! Then when his final two of six children are “old enough” to understand who he really is Bruce FINALLY decides to pull the trigger on becoming his true self 30+ years later after he first revealed who he was.

He was NOT honest with the second two women that he married when he romanced them, when he married them or when he got them pregnant. He partially abandoned his first FOUR children. But none of this is being talked about. All we are hearing is how “BRAVE” Bruce was in his interview with Diane Sawyer. How Bruce/Caitlyn is a HERO for the Trans movement. A “hero” by definition is someone who does the right thing in the face of adversity, no matter the consequences, because it is RIGHT not because it is easy or convenient. I see a person who has gotten to a phase in their life where they have NOTHING to lose. So why not? It is easy to do it now. So many people have come before her. Paved the way with their blood sweat and tears and some with their lives. 

Now he is she. She is Caitlyn. As she put it in the interview with Diane Sawyer, “She” has no secrets. I get it. Caitlyn is a clean slate. She is a new person, she has just been born. And honestly, sincerely, hooray for that. Hooray that you have millions of dollars to become Caitlyn. Hooray that you get the cover of Vanity Fair. But I have a friend transitioning. Where is her parade? Where are all the parades for the THOUSANDS of transpeople out there that AREN’T reality show famous? Will Caitlyn’s story make Trans less of a dirty word? I hope so. That has been FAR too long in coming. But there were plenty of REAL  TransHERO’s before her. (Laverne Cox, Aydian Dowling and Kate Bornstein to name just a few.)

Caitlyn didn’t invent this. She isn’t the first. And she won’t be the last. But in my opinion, because Caitlyn has been born into FAME, she has the responsibility and DUTY to clean up Bruce’s mess and fix the mistakes that he made. Because they are HUGE and glaring. Good luck to her. My less than favorable opinion of Caitlyn has nothing to do with her Transition or that she transitioned. She is beautiful and has a new life ahead of her. BUT the road taken to her new shiny life is paved with too many lies and too many lives hurt in the process for me to jump up and down on the couch for her. She needs to make right what was done in the past. Maybe this is just my own Daddy issues talking, having been abandoned by my own father.

But as a parent I know one truth to be above all others, my happiness is tied FOREVER to the happiness of my children. There is NOTHING more important in the world than being there for my kids and being in their lives as much as I can. Nothing. Living your truth is part of that. I get that. But living your truth can never come at the cost of others. It can never come on the back of a gigantic lie. The abandonment, I am just having a really hard time moving past that. I feel that I just can’t celebrate her. Because she isn’t a hero. She is a beautiful woman, who I wish nothing but happiness for, but I am not baking a cake.

Join the discussion 9 Comments

  • Tracy Samson says:

    This topic is crazy to me. I think the media has gone overboard in the “hero” dept. But at the same time I think that by what she has chosen to do..to make this change in the public eye..has saved so many lives. It has forced people to realize that this is a REAL thing. I was disheartened to read about how Bruce abandoned his children. I will never understand that. But then I also dont get how “so called” christian people pass so much judgement. At the end of the day..this is between Jenner and her God. I hope she finds peace and happiness. I hope that because of her act she helps others not have to live so many years in a lie. If other lifestyles were accepted in our society…there would be not be as much needless suffering from those who are going through it and those who are associated with it by no fault of their own. It always comes down to this….You don’t know another’s battle or journey..so be kind..be supportive..be understanding.

    • Nora says:

      I am happy that she finally transitioned. I support everyone who is transitioning and who wants to do that. My opinion of her has zero to do with that aspect of her life. In fact that is the only thing that I like about her. I just don’t like that she is being championed as the supreme trans example. She isn’t. There are so many out there, children who are transitioning, many who have transitioned before her and many who will come after her. I think that getting the word out about Trans and making Transgender a normality is vital. It is vital for everyone on the planet that people are allowed to be who they truly are. And I am in no way judging her for transitioning. This is solely about what took place before that. I think the label “hero” is completely inappropriate for her. A hero is someone who does what needs to be done despite danger, despite consequences. They do it because it is right no matter what happens to them. A real Trans Hero to me is Kristen Beck. She was a NAVY SEAL and came out publicly and is now planning to run for congress. That is a hero. Caitlyn is a lovely woman and I wish the best for her but she is not a hero.

  • Tracy Samson says:

    I know you are not judging. I was talking about people in general. I am sorry if you thought i was meaning you. I was more venting my feelings about the general publics reaction. There has been so many people on my fb book who claim to be these great christians…and they are the first to judge! It makes me crazy!! I dont comment on celebrity things too much, they get enough press as it is! I agree that the media has created this “hero” thing around her. The problem is..it is going to backlash against Caitlyn…even though she has never claimed (as far as i know) that she is a “hero”

  • mk says:

    When a person is transitioning their gender, it probably takes up all their time, money, energy, thinking, activities, dreaming, etc. How do I look, how do I want to look, how can I get that look, what parts of my body are good/bad, how can I pay for all this, which clothes make me look perfect, how to apply makeup, where can I show off my appearance and get the attention I seek… and there’s the hormones and surgeries… I don’t see how good parenting fits into this lifestyle, at least not prior to, during, or just after the transitioning is in process. I think you make some good points.

  • James says:

    Thank you for your thoughts, I am in complete agreement w/ you.

  • Zlica says:

    He comes across as a troubled and unstable person. Some people like to wear costumes. Some people like to get reactions based on their looks. Former superstar athletes have a very difficult time adjusting to civilian life. I don’t care – do what you like, but not heroic to me.

  • Ann says:

    I just saw your video on Underground Bunker and am excited to watch your series. Thank you for this post. My issue with Jenner is that he is a wealthy white man who is appropriating and objectifying woman by presenting himself as a 65 year old sex object. She/he is feeding into the Kardashian narcissistic machine by spending so much money trying to look like a 35 year old woman. This perpetuates the worship of “youth culture” and reinforces the pressure for women to obsess over their aging faces and bodies. As a 58 year old woman, I believe Jenner is setting a horrible example for his two daughters who are already being sexualized for profit! My opinion may be unpopular, but I would respect Jenner more if some of the money spent on designer clothes, hair extensions and make-up artists would be used to help others who are dealing with gender issues. Thanks!

  • Roy Steele says:

    I largely agree with your sentiments. Caitlyn Jenner is not my hero, and I can understand why some view her as such. I think that Caitlyn is brave and courageous for sharing her story in such a public way. She’s committed to working with the trans and LGBTQ community, and if she has a positive impact on one narrow mind, or inspires and instills confidence in one trans teenager, I will applaud her efforts. No one is perfect. Who are we to judge her choices, or criticize her family, and second guess what she should have done in the past? The truth of the matter is that it took 65 years for Caitlyn Jenner to come out. At sixty five she’s discovering who she is as a woman. In the future, she might decide to wear less makeup, or more foundation and mascara, or she might learn that she prefers flats over heels. Regardless, that’s her journey and she’s in for a hell of a ride. I believe that Caitlyn Jenner’s heart is in the right place, and that’s what really matters.

  • Troy Christman says:

    Well said, Nora!
    Thank you 🙂

Leave a Reply